Xero vs QuickBooks vs FreeAgent vs Sage for landlords: how to choose
What changed on : We added a section on choosing between Sage and FreeAgent, using the prices and features we already show for both.
Every change to this guide
- : We added a section on choosing between Sage and FreeAgent, using the prices and features we already show for both.
- : We added a sentence that gives the median paid starting price from our latest quarterly price report, with links to that report and to our record of price changes.
- : The answer on switching later now quotes GOV.UK, which says you do not need to import earlier years' records into new software, in place of our line about moving them.
- : We now take every price, plan and feature in this guide from the facts we hold for each product, and removed or softened claims we could not check.
New and revised guides also appear in a feed you can follow in a feed reader.
acrenvo.com/guides/xero-quickbooks-freeagent-sage-compared, last reviewed 25 October 2026
Xero, QuickBooks, FreeAgent and Sage are familiar names, but they are not interchangeable landlord products. One may suit a growing portfolio and accountant-led bookkeeping, while another makes more sense for a single property, a qualifying bank account or a strict monthly budget.
The comparison is most useful when it starts from the work you need to do. Think about how many properties need separating, whether a sole trade sits beside the rent, whether ownership is shared and where the records will be kept. Those details usually tell you more than the length of a feature list.
We last checked the prices for Sage on 12 September 2026, so they are due a fresh check. The provider's website shows today's price.
Xero tends to suit people who want room for the setup to grow
Xero offers five plans, so there is room to move up as the work changes. It can support multi-property records, self-employment alongside rent, payroll and direct accountant access, so it is often considered when the bookkeeping is likely to expand. An accountant or bookkeeper who already works in Xero can also reduce the effort of sharing and reviewing records.
A single-property landlord with no other business may not use enough of that breadth to justify the subscription. Xero’s regular prices now include its September 2026 increase and run from £7 plus VAT a month on the Simple plan to £70 plus VAT a month on Ultimate, before any introductory offer for new customers.
QuickBooks is the mainstream option to check when cost is high on the list
The QuickBooks plans most relevant here are Sole Trader Plus, at £10 plus VAT a month, and Simple Start, at £18 plus VAT a month. Those are the regular prices for one business when checked on 3 November 2026, and introductory offers may apply. Simple Start is the first plan that also handles Making Tax Digital (MTD) for VAT returns. QuickBooks provides mobile record entry, which may matter if you expect to log expenses while away from a laptop.
QuickBooks does not provide the same property-specific portfolio structure as a landlord platform, and the comparison table does not list multi-property support for it. Its setup guidance asks for a separate account for each business or property income source, and its joint-property support is not confirmed, so separating several properties or sharing ownership may need more manual organisation. Because the combined price for mixed income has not been confirmed, the selector does not suggest QuickBooks for someone with both rent and a trade. That can be acceptable for one property or a single sole trade, while a larger portfolio may benefit from a product built around property-level records.
FreeAgent is strongest when the bank connection makes the price work
A qualifying NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle business account can include FreeAgent without a separate software subscription. Outside that arrangement it is a paid product, with direct prices that differ for unincorporated landlords and sole traders: £10 plus VAT a month for a landlord and £19 plus VAT a month for a sole trader, which are the regular prices before any introductory offer. So it is worth checking the banking condition before you count FreeAgent as a free option.
Beyond the price, FreeAgent supports jointly owned property, and joint owners are among the people it is listed as suiting. If you and a partner or a sibling own something together, check how the split is recorded before you commit. It also covers self-employment alongside property, although FreeAgent’s own setup guidance needs separate Landlord and Sole Trader accounts for that. With a qualifying bank, the pair costs £10 plus VAT a month, because only the landlord account is charged; without one, the two direct accounts together cost £29 plus VAT a month at the regular price.
Sage is worth knowing about because its free tier changes the comparison
Sage Sole Trader’s free tier does not expire like a trial, and it covers one income source. It is capped at five sales invoices and 25 automatically categorised transactions a month, while manual records are not capped, so it suits someone with straightforward, low-volume affairs. The paid tier was listed at £7 plus VAT a month when checked on 12 September 2026, which is the regular price before any introductory discount.
The cap makes the fit easier to judge than a vague “free” promise. A landlord with several properties, frequent transactions, joint ownership or a separate trade should check the current feature list and paid tier before assuming the free product can maintain every required record.
Sage or FreeAgent for a sole trader or landlord
If cost comes first, Sage and FreeAgent are the two of these four with a free way in, and the choice between them turns on the condition attached to each. FreeAgent is free only alongside a qualifying NatWest, RBS, Ulster Bank or Mettle business account. Sage Sole Trader’s free tier needs no particular bank, but it covers one income source and is capped at five sales invoices and 25 automatically categorised transactions a month.
Without one of those bank accounts, the comparison comes down to the paid prices. Sage’s paid tier was £7 plus VAT a month when we checked it, and FreeAgent charges £10 plus VAT a month for a landlord or £19 plus VAT a month for a sole trader.
Having rent and a trade together changes the comparison. Sage’s free tier does not cover mixed income, so you would need to check what its paid tier offers. FreeAgent covers both through its separate Landlord and Sole Trader accounts, at £10 plus VAT a month with a qualifying bank or £29 plus VAT a month without one. Both support jointly owned property and several properties, so neither is ruled out for a landlord who shares ownership. FreeAgent includes mileage tracking and Sage Sole Trader does not, which may matter if you drive for your trade.
How the shape of your work points to one of the four
A qualifying bank account can put FreeAgent at the front of the cost comparison. Several properties, payroll or an accountant already working in Xero can make Xero’s broader setup worthwhile. QuickBooks is a stronger candidate when one property or a single sole trade, together with mobile record entry, matters more than portfolio features. Sage’s capped free tier suits the narrowest, lowest-volume setup. Each conclusion changes when joint ownership or mixed income adds another set of records.
None of that accounts for the situations that make this harder than a four-way pick, though: a former holiday let, property split between an SPV and your own name, living abroad, or combining rent with a trade. Those change the calculation enough that they get their own guides rather than a paragraph here, and they’re worth reading before you choose a product.
If you would rather answer up to ten questions and have the list filtered for you than cross-reference four sets of pricing pages yourself, the selector does that for you. The full comparison sets out the prices and features of every product we compare, these four and the landlord-specialist options together. If two of the four are already on your shortlist, we also set them out a pair at a time, for FreeAgent and QuickBooks, QuickBooks and Sage, and QuickBooks and Xero. Across the products we compare, the median paid starting price for July to September 2026 was £8.13 a month, as our quarterly price reports show, and our record of price changes dates each move.
Before choosing between the big names, test the practical fit
Is any of these free for everyone?
None of the four is free in every situation. Sage Sole Trader's free tier needs no qualifying bank account and does not expire like a trial, but it covers one income source and is capped at five sales invoices and 25 automatically categorised transactions a month. FreeAgent is also free, but only with a qualifying NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland, Ulster Bank or Mettle business account.
Which one is easiest if I'm doing this from my phone?
QuickBooks lists mobile record entry among its features, and FreeAgent, Xero and Sage also provide mobile apps, so test the property and reporting tasks you need on your phone before choosing on that basis.
Can I switch later if I pick wrong?
You can switch to other software later, and GOV.UK says: “You can change the software you use for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax at any time, but you may find it easier to change your software at the end of the tax year.” If you move after the end of a tax year, GOV.UK says: “You do not need to import your digital records from previous tax years into the new software.” You need to store your digital records from previous tax years securely and be able to access them. Moving partway through a year asks more of you, and the guide to changing MTD software explains what GOV.UK says to do then.
More in: Choosing and setting up software
Next in this stage
Keeping your spreadsheet for MTD: bridging software and digital links
If you already keep tidy records in a spreadsheet, MTD for Income Tax does not have to mean starting again. This guide explains what HMRC asks of your records, what bridging software does, how digital links work, and which bridging tools we compare.
Other guides in this stage
Sources
This is general information, not tax advice. For advice on your own situation, speak to an accountant or tax adviser.